Menupickcom lists publicly available information. We are not affiliated with the restaurants shown. How we source and check listings

Menupickcom

Paisanos Pizza (New City) menu

17 dishes across 5 sections Inexpensive Pizza Restaurant

Prices transcribed from the printed menu, last checked

Menu Paisanos Pizza (New City) photo menu 1
Photographed in store, August 2026. See all 4 pages

Photos of the printed menu

Photographed in store in August 2026. The dish list below covers everything we could read clearly; the full card has more.

Appetizers 24 dishes

  • Fried Calamari $15.08

    It comes with marinara sauce

  • Onion Rings $9.62

    With tomato sauce

  • Mozzarella Sticks $10.92

    6 pieces. With tomato sauce

  • Fried Mushrooms $9.88

    With tomato sauce

  • Buffalo Hot Breaded Wings $13.51

    10 pieces.

  • Garlic Bread $4.42

    With tomato sauce

  • Garlic Knots $5.46

    6 pieces. With side of tomato sauce

  • Eggplant Rollatini $11.96

    2 pieces. Tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese

  • Pepperoni Twists $1.56

    Mozzarella and pepperoni

  • Pierogies $9.35

  • Boneless Wings $11.96

    10 pieces.

  • Jamaican Meat Patty $4.94

  • Zucchini Sticks $10.35

    With tomato sauce

  • Chicken Fingers & Fries $11.96

    5 pieces. Come with honey mustard.

  • Calamari & Marinara Sauce $15.08

  • Mussels Marinara $14.55

  • No Breaded Wings $10.35

  • Bruschetta $9.88

    Tomatoes, basil, onion & fresh mozzarella

  • Sesame Ginger Calamari $17.63

    Fried calamari tossed in ginger sauce, sesame with mango, roasted peppers, and kalamata olives

  • Mozzarella Crostini $8.27

    Breaded fresh mozzarella & ham served with marinara sauce

  • Rice Ball $5.72

    Rice, cheese, sauce, peas, and ground beef rolled & lightly fried

  • Paisanos Calamari $17.16

    Fried calamari in sauteed cherry tomatoes, scallion onions in balsamic glaze

  • Appetizer For 2 $16.12

    Served 2 people. Mozzarella sticks, chicken fingers, fried mushrooms & zucchini sticks

  • French Fries $5.00

Traditional Pizza 14 dishes

  • Plain Cheese Pizza $10.40

    Classic cheese or create your own pizza

  • Plain White Ricotta Pizza $17.42

  • Chicken Parmigiana Pizza $21.32

    It comes chicken, tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese

  • BBQ Chicken Pizza $21.32

    Comes with chicken, mozzarella and BBQ sauce

  • Meat Lovers Pizza $21.32

    Ham, meatballs, sausage & pepperoni

  • Penne Alla Vodka Pizza $21.32

    Mozzarella cheese, vodka sauce

  • Hawaiian Pizza $21.32

    Ham & pineapple

  • Cheesesteak Pizza $21.32

    Steak, American cheese and onions

  • Paisano Special Pizza $21.32

    Peppers, onions, mushrooms, pepperoni and sausage

  • Vegetable Special Pizza $21.32

    Mushroom, broccoli, tomatoes, and spinach

  • Salad Pizza $21.32

    Lettuce, tomatoes, onions and cucumbers

  • White Broccoli Pizza $21.32

    Ricotta cheese and broccoli

  • White Pizza with Tomatoes $21.32

    Ricotta cheese and tomatoes

  • Chicken Marsala Pizza $23.40

    Chicken, mozzarella and mushrooms

Specialty and Squared Sicilian Pizza 21 dishes

  • Stuffed Pizza $27.10

    Large. Our famous stuffed steak, cheese and onions pie

  • Baked Ziti Pizza $21.32

    Tomato sauce and Mozzarella cheese

  • Eggplant Pizza with Ricotta $21.32

    Pizza sauce, eggplant and ricotta cheese

  • Buffalo Chicken Pizza $21.32

    Buffalo chicken and mozzarella cheese

  • Chicken Parmigiana Pizza $21.32

    Chicken cutlet, tomato sauce and mozzarella cheese

  • Taco Pizza $23.40

    Ground beef, cheddar cheese, lettuce and tomatoes, and mozzarella cheese

  • Four Cheese Pizza $21.32

    Mozzarella, ricotta, provolone and cheddar cheese

  • BBQ Chicken Pizza $21.32

    BBQ sauce, chicken cutlet and mozzarella

  • Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza $21.32

    Chicken cutlet, bacon, ranch sauce, and mozzarella cheese

  • Chicken Caesar Salad Pizza $23.40

    Grilled chicken, Romaine lettuce and Caesar dressing and mozzarella cheese

  • Margherita Pizza $21.32

    San Marzano, tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, and basil

  • Cauliflower Pizza $16.12

    Cauliflower crust, with pizza sauce and mozzarella cheese

  • Gluten Free Pizza $16.12

  • Penne Vodka Pie $22.21

  • Half & Half Specialty Pizza $21.32

  • Grandma Sicilian Pizza $24.96

    Pesto sauce, fresh mozzarella cheese, basil, and marinara sauce

  • Plain Sicilian Pizza $23.40

    Square.

  • Drunken Grandma Sicilian Pizza $24.95

    It comes with vodka sauce

  • Sicilian Paisano Special Pizza $27.03

    Peppers, onions, mushrooms, pepperoni and sausage

  • Fresca Sicilian Pizza $24.95

    Zucchini, onions, fresh tomatoes and fresh mushrooms

  • Sicilian Vegetable Special Pizza $25.99

    Square. Mushroom, broccoli, tomatoes, and spinach

Slices 7 dishes

  • Plain Slice $3.50

  • Specialty Slice $4.75

  • Sicilian Slice $4.75

  • Garlic Knots $3.00

  • Soda $2.25

  • Pepperoni Slice $4.00

  • Plain Slice/ No Topping $3.50

Panini's & Calzones 11 dishes

  • Calzone $9.35

    Mozzarella cheese and tomato sauce

  • Paisano Panini $13.51

    Grilled chicken, eggplant, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers

  • Chicken Calzone $12.37

    Breaded or grilled chicken, mozzarella and ricotta cheese

  • Grilled Cheese Pesto Panini $13.51

    Grilled chicken, portabella, mushrooms, cheese

  • Vegetable Special Calzone $12.37

    Broccoli, mushrooms, spinach, tomatoes

  • Caprese Panini $13.51

    Tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, basil, balsamic

  • Godfather Panini $13.51

    Grilled chicken, portabella, mushrooms, eggplant & fresh mozzarella

  • Grilled Chicken Balsamic Panini $13.51

    Grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers

  • Vegetable Panini $13.51

    Fried eggplant, zucchini, roasted peppers, portabella mushrooms, fresh mozzarella, and balsamic dressing

  • Turkey Club Panini $13.51

    Turkey, bacon, American cheese, lettuce, tomato, mayo

  • Antipasto Panini $13.51

    Grilled chicken, roasted red peppers, sundried tomatoes, prosciutto, artichokes, provolone cheese, Italian dressing

From the Grill, Subs and Wraps 36 dishes

  • Tuna Fish Sub $11.44

    Lettuce, tomatoes and onions. Served on toasted bread

  • Veal Parm Sub $14.03

    Served on toasted bread

  • Sausage & Egg Sub $11.44

    Served on toasted bread

  • Roast Beef Sub $11.44

    Lettuce, tomatoes and onions. Served on toasted bread

  • Chicken Parm Sub $11.44

    Served on toasted bread

  • Italian Sub $11.44

    Ham, provolone, and salami, lettuce, tomatoes and onions. Served on toasted bread

  • Shrimp Parm Sub $14.03

    Served on toasted bread

  • Turkey & Cheese Sub $11.44

    Lettuce, tomatoes and onions. Served on toasted bread

  • Eggplant Parm Sub $11.44

    Served on toasted bread

  • Prosciutto Sub $11.44

    Fresh mozzarella & roasted peppers, lettuce, tomatoes and onions

  • Peppers & Egg Sub $11.44

    Served on toasted bread

  • Turkey Sub $11.44

    Provolone cheese & bacon with lettuce, tomatoes, and onions. Served on toasted bread

  • Meatball Parm Sub $11.44

    Served on toasted bread

  • Eggplant & Provolone Cheese Sub $11.91

    Served on toasted bread

  • Sausage Parm Sub $11.44

    Sausage, peppers & onions with red sauce. Served on toasted bread

  • Chicken California Sub $11.44

    Lettuce, tomatoes, mayo & onions. Served on toasted bread

  • Crispy Fried Chicken Sub $11.44

    American cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, bacon, ranch dressing. Served on toasted bread

  • Breaded Eggplant Sub $11.91

    Arugula, roasted red peppers, fresh mozzarella, balsamic dressing. Served on toasted bread

  • Paisano Special Sub $14.03

    Grilled chicken, roasted red peppers, fried eggplant, and provolone cheese. Served on toasted bread

  • House Cheesesteak Sandwich $12.47

    Mushrooms, peppers & onions. Served on toasted bread

  • Cheesesteak California Sandwich $12.47

    Lettuce, tomato, onions & mayo. Served on toasted bread

  • Grilled Chicken California Sandwich $11.43

    Lettuce, tomato, onions & mayo. Served on toasted bread

  • Cheeseburger Deluxe $10.92

    Fries, lettuce, tomatoes & onions. Served on toasted bread

  • Pizza Burger $12.43

    Mozzarella cheese, and marinara sauce. Served on toasted bread

  • Italian Burger $12.43

    Grilled onions, peppers, mushrooms, and provolone cheese. Served on toasted bread

  • Western Burger $12.47

    Grilled onions, bacon, cheddar cheese, and BBQ sauce. Served on toasted bread

  • Cheesesteak Sandwich $11.44

    Served on toasted bread

  • Gyro with French Fries $11.43

  • Chicken Caesar Wrap $12.47

    Lettuce and Caesar dressing. With your choice of French fries or salad

  • BLT Wrap $12.47

    Bacon, lettuce, tomatoes and mayo. With your choice of French fries or salad

  • Chicken Bacon & Ranch Wrap $12.47

    Lettuce, tomatoes, and ranch dressing. With your choice of French fries or salad

  • Buffalo Wrap $12.47

    Lettuce, tomatoes and hot sauce. With your choice of French fries or salad

  • Brooklyn Wrap $12.47

    Grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella, and roasted red peppers. With your choice of French fries or salad

  • Grilled Chicken Wrap $12.47

    Lettuce, tomatoes, onions, and mayo. With your choice of French fries or salad

  • Americano Wrap $12.47

    Ham, salami, provolone, lettuce, tomato, and mayo. With your choice of French fries or salad

  • Turkey Provolone Wrap $12.47

    Lettuce, tomato, onions, and mayo. With your choice of French fries or salad

Chicken, Veal and Seafood 38 dishes

  • Grilled Chicken & Grilled Vegetables $21.84

    Grilled chicken with mushrooms, onions, zucchini, and peppers. (No pasta). Served with soup or salad & garlic bread or regular bread

  • Chicken Florentina $21.84

    Slices of chicken sautéed in white wine, topped with fresh tomatoes, spinach & mozzarella cheese in a light red sauce. Served with soup or salad & garlic bread or regular bread

  • Chicken Rollatini $23.92

    Breaded chicken cutlet stuffed with fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers, and prosciutto in a crema sauce. Served with soup or salad & garlic bread or regular bread

  • Chicken Principesa $21.84

    Sautéed chicken, eggplant, tomatoes, peas, mozzarella cheese, and light marinara sauce. Served with soup or salad & garlic bread or regular bread

  • Chicken Aurora $23.40

    Breaded chicken, sun dried tomato, mozzarella cheese, pink sauce parmigiana. Served with soup or salad & garlic bread or regular bread

  • Chicken Murphy $21.84

    Sautéed chicken, onions, peppers, potatoes, mushrooms, and brown sauce. Served with soup or salad & garlic bread or regular bread

  • Chicken Paisano $21.84

    Grilled chicken with bowtie pasta, peas, onions in garlic & oil. Served with soup or salad & garlic bread or regular bread

  • Chicken Scarparielo $21.84

    Chicken breast, hot peppers, sautéed with hot cherry peppers & sausage on white sauce. Served with soup or salad & garlic bread or regular bread

  • Chicken Saltimbocca $21.84

    Slices of chicken or light brown sauce with prosciutto and spinach sautéed & topped with mozzarella. Served with soup or salad & garlic bread or regular bread

  • Chicken Piccata $21.84

    Slices of chicken sautéed in a white wine sauce with capers. Served with soup or salad & garlic bread or regular bread

  • Chicken Cacciatore $21.84

    With peppers and mushrooms, onions & red sauce. Served with soup or salad & garlic bread or regular bread

  • Chicken Alfredo $21.84

    Sliced chicken with broccoli & sweet peas in Alfredo sauce. Served with soup or salad & garlic bread or regular bread

  • Chicken Reale $21.84

    Topped with eggplant & mozzarella in brown sauce

  • Chicken Scampi $21.84

    White sauce, white wine garlic & lemon. Served with soup or salad & garlic bread or regular bread

  • Chicken Francese $21.84

    Sautéed in butter and lemon. Served with soup or salad & garlic bread or regular bread

  • Chicken Marsala $21.84

    With mushrooms & marsala wine. Served with soup or salad & garlic bread or regular bread.

  • Chicken Broccoli $21.84

    Sautéed in a light marinara sauce Served with soup or salad & garlic bread or regular bread.

  • Chicken Parm $21.00

    Served with soup or salad & garlic bread or regular bread.

  • Veal Florentina $22.88

    Slices of veal sautéed in white wine, topped with fresh tomatoes, spinach & mozzarella cheese in a light red sauce. Served with soup or salad & garlic bread or regular bread.

  • Veal Scarparielo $22.88

    Veal, hot peppers, sautéed with hot cherry peppers & sausage on white sauce. Served with soup or salad & garlic bread or regular bread.

  • Veal Saltimbocca $22.88

    Veal or light brown sauce with prosciutto and spinach sautéed & topped with mozzarella. Served with soup or salad & garlic bread or regular bread.

  • Veal Piccata $22.88

    Veal sautéed in a white wine sauce with capers. Served with soup or salad & garlic bread or regular bread.

  • Veal Cacciatore $22.88

    With peppers and mushrooms, onions & red sauce. Served with soup or salad & garlic bread or regular bread.

  • Veal Alfredo $22.88

    Sliced Veal with broccoli & sweet peas in Alfredo sauce. Served with soup or salad & garlic bread or regular bread.

  • Veal Reale $22.88

    Topped with eggplant & mozzarella in brown sauce. Served with soup or salad & garlic bread or regular bread.

  • Veal Scampi $22.88

    White sauce, white wine garlic & lemon. Served with soup or salad & garlic bread or regular bread.

  • Veal Francese $22.88

    Sautéed in butter and lemon. Served with soup or salad & garlic bread or regular bread.

  • Veal Marsala $22.88

    With mushrooms & marsala wine. Served with soup or salad & garlic bread or regular bread.

  • Veal Broccoli $22.88

    Sautéed in a light marinara sauce. Served with soup or salad & garlic bread or regular bread.

  • Veal Parmigiana $22.00

    Served with soup or salad & garlic bread or regular bread.

  • Shrimp Scampi $23.92

    White wine, garlic & lemon sauce. Served with soup or salad & garlic bread or regular bread.

  • Shrimp Alfredo $23.92

    Served with soup or salad & garlic bread or regular bread.

  • Shrimp Francese $23.92

    Sautéed in butter and lemon. Served with soup or salad & garlic bread or regular bread.

  • Shrimp Marinara $23.92

    Served with soup or salad & garlic bread or regular bread.

  • Clams & Shrimp $23.92

    With red sauce. Served with soup or salad & garlic bread or regular bread.

  • Calamari Marinara $20.79

    With light sauce. Served with soup or salad & garlic bread or regular bread.

  • Clams Sauce $23.92

    Red or white. Served with soup or salad & garlic bread or regular bread.

  • Mussels $20.79

    Red or white. Served with soup or salad & garlic bread or regular bread.

Pasta, Baked Pasta & Dinners 23 dishes

  • Pasta with Meat Sauce $17.67

    Served with soup or salad & garlic bread or regular bread

  • Spaghetti with Meatballs $18.20

    Served with soup or salad & garlic bread or regular bread

  • Pasta with Sausage $18.20

    Served with soup or salad & garlic bread or regular bread

  • Pasta with Alfredo Sauce $18.71

    Served with soup or salad & garlic bread or regular bread

  • Pasta with Garlic & Oil $15.59

    Served with soup or salad & garlic bread or regular bread

  • Pasta Bolognese $17.67

    Meat sauce with mushrooms. Served with soup or salad & garlic bread or regular bread

  • Pasta with Tomato Sauce $15.59

    Smooth red sauce. Served with soup or salad & garlic bread or regular bread

  • Pasta with Vodka Sauce $17.67

    Red onions & vodka sauce. Served with soup or salad & garlic bread or regular bread

  • Pasta with Marinara Sauce $16.63

    Red sauce with chunks of garlic. Served with soup or salad & garlic bread or regular bread

  • Fettuccini Carbonara $18.71

    Pasta made with eggs, onions & bacon in a cream sauce. Served with soup or salad & garlic bread or regular bread

  • Pasta Arrabiata $18.71

    Red onions, black olives, capers, crushed peppers, and marinated sauce. Served with soup or salad & garlic bread or regular bread

  • Stuffed Shells $18.71

    Served with soup or salad & garlic bread or regular bread

  • Baked Manicotti $18.71

    Served with soup or salad & garlic bread or regular bread

  • Baked Cheese Ravioli $18.71

    Served with soup or salad & garlic bread or regular bread

  • Eggplant Rollatini $18.71

    Served with soup or salad & garlic bread or regular bread

  • Eggplant Parmigiana $18.71

    Served with soup or salad & garlic bread or regular bread

  • Sausage Parmigiana $18.71

    Served with soup or salad & garlic bread or regular bread

  • Meatballs Parmigiana $18.71

    Served with soup or salad & garlic bread or regular bread

  • Sausage & Peppers $18.71

    Served with soup or salad & garlic bread or regular bread

  • Homemade Lasagna $18.71

    Served with soup or salad & garlic bread or regular bread

  • Baked Tortellini $18.71

    With red sauce. Served with soup or salad & garlic bread or regular bread

  • Baked Ziti $18.71

    In a tomato sauce with ricotta & melted mozzarella. Served with soup or salad & garlic bread or regular bread

  • Baked Ziti Sicilian Style $18.71

    Eggplant & ricotta cheese in tomato sauce with melted mozzarella. Served with soup or salad & garlic bread or regular bread

Soups & Salads 21 dishes

  • Caesar Salad $9.10

    Romaine lettuce, croutons, shredded mozzarella, gravy cheese, and Caesar dressing on the side.

  • Pasta Fagioli Soup $7.28

  • Chicken Caesar Salad $13.51

    Chicken, romaine lettuce, croutons, shredded mozzarella, gravy cheese, and Caesar dressing on the side.

  • Minestrone Soup $7.28

  • Chef Salad $14.03

    Lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions, roasted red peppers, green olives, turkey, ham, American cheese, and fresh mozzarella.

  • Chicken Tortellini Soup $7.28

  • Tossed Salad $9.10

    Lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions, roasted red peppers, green olives.

  • Chicken Noodle Soup $7.28

  • Grilled Chicken Salad $13.51

    Grilled chicken, lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions, roasted red peppers, green olives.

  • Stracciatella Soup $7.28

  • Antipasto Salad $10.92

    Ham, salami, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions, roasted red peppers, green olives.

  • Fresh Mozzarella, Tomato & Roasted Peppers Salad $11.96

  • Grilled Shrimp Avocado Salad $13.26

    Baby spinach with red onions, sliced almonds, and tomatoes

  • Buffalo Chicken Salad $13.26

    Chicken sautéed with our homemade buffalo sauce over a garden salad

  • Cobb Salad $14.55

    Romaine lettuce, avocado, tomato, bacon, crumbled bleu cheese, and a hard-boiled egg

  • Apple Salad $12.95

    Granny smith apples, walnuts, dried cranberries, crumbled bleu cheese, and mixed greens

  • Pear Salad $12.95

    Pears, walnuts, dried cranberries, crumbled blue cheese, and mixed greens

  • Paisano Salad $16.38

    Chopped eggplant and chopped grilled chicken with roasted peppers, and fresh mozzarella over a chopped garden salad

  • Cranberry Walnut Salad $10.14

    Baby spring greens, dried cranberries, a crumble of tangy feta cheese, and toasted walnuts smothered with red raspberry vianigrette dressing

  • L'Insalata Romana Salad $14.51

    Grilled mushrooms & grilled chicken strips with roasted red peppers, fresh mozzarella and served over a bed of romaine lettuce

  • Extra Dressing $0.75

Baked Rolls & Side Orders 10 dishes

  • Spinach $9.35

  • Sausage Roll $9.88

    Sausage, peppers and onions, and mozzarella cheese.

  • Side of Sausage $9.35

  • Chicken Roll $11.43

    Filled with mozzarella

  • Side of Grilled Chicken $7.50

  • Side of Meatballs $8.31

  • Pepperoni Roll $10.39

    Pepperoni and cheese

  • Broccoli $8.27

  • Stromboli $9.88

    Filled with peppers, onions with mozzarella

  • Broccoli Rabe $9.35

Combo Specials 4 dishes

  • Family Deal (Dinner Special) $38.50

  • Large Pizza W/ Wings Special $34.99

  • Large Pizza W/ Antipasto $38.99

  • Large Pizza W/ Baked Penne $41.99

Children Menu 6 dishes

  • Kid's Spaghetti with Tomato Sauce $8.84

  • Kid's Spaghetti with Sausage $8.84

  • Kid's Spaghetti with Meatball $8.84

  • Kid's Chicken Fingers $8.84

    With French fries

  • Kid's Ravioli $8.84

    Filled with mozzarella cheese.

  • Kids Penne with Butter $9.21

Desserts 4 dishes

  • New York Cheesecake $4.68

  • Cannoli $4.16

  • Tiramisu Cake $4.68

  • Zeppolis $6.24

Beverages 7 dishes

  • Soda $2.86

  • Tea $2.86

  • Lemonade $2.86

  • Apple Juice $2.86

  • Orange Juice $2.86

  • Fountain Soda $3.11

  • Can $2.25

Special Lunch Menu 11 dishes

  • Pasta with Clam Sauce Lunch $14.04

    Red or white. Served with choice of pasta.

  • Pasta with Meat Sauce Lunch $11.70

    Served with choice of pasta.

  • Penne Vodka Lunch $10.92

    Served with choice of pasta.

  • Pasta with Meatballs Lunch $10.40

    Served with choice of pasta.

  • Pasta with Sausage Lunch $10.40

    Served with choice of pasta.

  • Pasta with Marinara Sauce Lunch $10.66

    Red sauce with chunks of tomatoes & garlic. Served with choice of pasta.

  • Pasta with Tomato Sauce Lunch $9.88

    Smooth red sauce. Served with choice of pasta.

  • Manicotti Lunch $10.92

    Served with choice of pasta.

  • Ravioli Lunch $10.92

    4 pieces

  • Chicken Parmigiana Lunch $13.50

    Served with choice of pasta.

  • Pasta with Broccoli Lunch $10.35

    Red or white sauce. Served with choice of pasta.

Monday Special 1 dishes

  • Two Hot or Cold Subs Monday Special $19.99

Sunday Thru Thursday Specials 1 dishes

  • 4 Specials Dinner $38.50

About these prices

Restaurants change prices without notice, and a menu photographed in August may already be out of date. Treat these figures as a guide, not a quote. If you spot a difference, tell us and we will re-check it.

Other menus in New City

Prices transcribed the same way, each with the date last checked.

All New City listings
Call Menu Directions